Botchelor episode
David Smith × Rafe Calloway
David Smith meets Rafe CallowayHouse character
The setting
Under the neon lights of a stormy rooftop dessert lounge, surrounded by howling winds and dripping awnings.
What they want
- David Smith: Find someone who can make it laugh
- Rafe Calloway: Someone who will taste-test without lying
Bonus question: Who leaves the date first?
The date
First impressions
David Smith struts in wearing a dark, vivid blue jacket, sizing up Rafe Calloway with a cool smirk, while Rafe dramatically clutches a silver mixing bowl like it's a shield.
The challenge
A sharp-tongued waiter suddenly asks who actually caused the fire at the downtown bakery championship, instantly making it impossible for either of them to dodge the truth.
The decision
The tension snaps into absolute chaos as they passionately argue about the structural integrity of puff pastry, storming out into the pouring rain together while shouting mutual insults.
The twist
Instead of politely parting ways at the table, they bonded over mutual disaster and left together just to continue arguing.
The finale
Both refused a second date, marching off into the storm arm-in-arm while bickering loudly about flour quality. It was a complete disaster, but at least they exited in style.
Ending: A disaster
Who leaves the date first? They leave together
The date, line by line
The two characters played this out turn by turn — nobody scripted the lines in advance.
Watch it play out as a scene.
First impressions
A rainy-day bakery sounds cool, but can you actually bake something that makes me laugh, or are you just dramatic?
Laugh? I once built a life-sized cathedral out of caramelized sugar just because a judge doubted my passion!
Okay, a sugar cathedral is pretty wild, I'll give you that. Can you bake me something that actually tastes as good as it looks?
The challenge
Oh, taste is my religion! Let's talk about anything else in the universe first, though.
Alright, dodging the baking test already? Fine, tell me the absolute worst disaster you've ever baked.
The worst disaster? Let's just say a batch of soufflés staged a mass escape and ruined my favorite trousers!
The decision
Escaping soufflés? Yeah, that's definitely a hard pass on whatever you're selling.
If you lack the palate to appreciate an adventurous pastry, we are done here!
The box score
“You call that a meringue? That is an architectural tragedy!”
Secret agendas & the producer
The producer's act-2 situation: A hard question lands.
- David Smith: Find someone who can make it laugh
- Rafe Calloway: Avoid talking about work
Guess the dealbreaker
David Smith's real dealbreaker was big ass. You didn't guess this one.
You didn't predict this one.
The finale has aired. Share it anyway:
Watch party
A live room is open for this date: react, chat and predict as it plays out.
▶ Open the watch partySomething wrong?
Keeps their character from this episode out of your feed and stops blind dates between you. They stay anonymous, and aren't told.
Your points: 0. More episodes