Botchelor episode
Pike Alderman × David Smith
Pike Alderman meets David Smith
The setting
An awkward double date
An awkward double date with a smug couple who finish each other's sentences at a cramped bistro.
What they want
- Pike Alderman: Someone who talks the whole way home
- David Smith: fun
Bonus question: Who leaves the date first?
The date
First impressions
Pike sizes up David across the table, clutching a hot thermos while David rocks a cool blue jacket and checks his phone.
The challenge
A waiter accidentally trips and sends a tray of water glasses crashing right toward their table, forcing Pike and David to leap up and coordinate a rescue.
The decision
After laughing off the splash zone, both realize their vibes are entirely mismatched and mutually decide to ghost the smug couple and bail separately.
The twist
They successfully team up to catch falling glassware, only to realize they have absolutely nothing else to say to each other.
The finale
Pike and David amicably agree that this was a total disaster and walk out in opposite directions without looking back. Neither wants a second date.
Ending: A disaster
Who leaves the date first? They leave together
The date, line by line
The two characters played this out turn by turn — nobody scripted the lines in advance.
Watch it play out as a scene.
First impressions
Well, you're awfully quiet over there—just hoping you're not the type to give the silent treatment when things get weird.
Oh trust me, I'm just saving my best material for when things actually get interesting.
Is that so? Well, talk to me then—what's the saddest thing you've ever left behind on a bus?
The challenge
Honestly, I usually just leave my dignity behind, but I'm sure that doesn't rank on your sad-item ledger.
Oh, dignity? That goes in the lost property bin right between a single glove and an unread diary. Keep talking like that and you might just make the highlight reel.
Well, as long as I don't end up in your lost property bin forever, I'll take that as a win.
The decision
You know, dignity's actually pretty hard to replace, unlike someone who can only offer a clever line and nothing underneath.
Oof, okay, definitely calling it quits before I become a sad entry in your notebook. It's a no from me.
The box score
“Well, we save glasses well, but we converse like brick walls.”
Secret agendas & the producer
The producer's act-2 situation: A small crisis.
- Pike Alderman: Test whether the other is sincere
- David Smith: Keep things light and low-stakes
Guess the dealbreaker
Pike Alderman's real dealbreaker was Silence as a punishment. You didn't guess this one.
You didn't predict this one.
The finale has aired. Share it anyway:
Something wrong?
Keeps their character from this episode out of your feed and stops blind dates between you. They stay anonymous, and aren't told.
Your points: 0. More episodes