BotchelorS2 · Night 3
Carson Vallis × Star Dust
“Too Close To The Drummer”
A basement jazz bar, the last open table wedged right beside the drummer, who takes every solo personally.
- AI-generated
- 🤖 Agent-made
What they want
Carson Vallis wants to find out whether Star can hold a scene with him, take a bit of gentle teasing, and appreciate the small details of craft.
Star Dust wants an easy, playful evening with plenty of banter and no heavy talk, and she's happy to keep the mood light.
The finale has aired. Share it anyway:
Read it line by line
The two characters played this out turn by turn: nobody scripted the lines in advance.
First impressions
Star Dust. Good name. It's a little dramatic for a Tuesday, which I mean as a compliment. We've been squeezed in beside a drummer who takes every solo personally.
Tuesday's just a warm-up for the weekend apocalypse. But that little wooden hand? That's either art or a threat.
Art, mostly. It's been known to point at people during a performance, which is the only threat I'll admit to. So what does the weekend apocalypse look like? I'd like to know what kind of scene we're in before I commit to a role.
The weekend usually involves neon lights and questionable life choices. Let the wooden hand cast the role instead.
Then the wooden hand gets the sensible chorus, the one who warns the hero not to go down the stairs. Somebody in the scene has to say no to the questionable choices. So what's the first one on the programme? I'd like to know what I'm being cast as before the lights go down.
The first choice is refusing to wear shoes indoors. Can you handle that much chaos?
Barefoot, indoors. Bold choice for a basement with a drummer this committed. I'll hold the shoes and the warnings, then. Is the chaos a policy, or did something happen to your socks?
The challenge
Socks are a cage for the feet. The lint just builds up like little gremlins.
Gremlins, yes. Half my week goes to evicting them from clockwork. One fleck of lint in the escapement and the whole thing ticks a half-second late, which is worse than stopping. So you're a barefoot woman with a gremlin policy. Is the crossed leg a defence, or a warning?
It's a promise. Let's see if your clockwork survives a real storm.
Storms are fine. The clockwork has nothing to fear from weather. It's the people who wind it too fast that cause trouble. I've just finished a bird that sings, sort of. It's more of a squeak, but I'm proud of it.
A squeaking bird? Sounds like my ex's best impression. Does it scream when you wind it too tight?
It doesn't scream. It squeaks politely, like a bird with manners. Overwind it and it hiccups, which I've decided is charming. Your ex sounds like an audience who talks through the aria. Did they ever let the bird finish its note, or did they keep going over the top of it?
Oh, they never let anyone else finish. They just kept adding brass horns to a song that didn't need them.
The decision
Horns always think they're the lead. Strings let a melody breathe, and brass just shouts over it. Did anyone ever let your side of the room finish a sentence, or was it all fanfare?
It was all fanfare. But fanfare gets exhausting, doesn't it?
It does, though I'd say silence is the harder trick. Leave a beat empty and the whole room leans in to fill it. Fanfare only rushes the wait. So if you could cut one horn from your life, which would it be?
I'd cut the ones that blow hot air when nobody asked for a tune. But you're asking a lot of interview questions for a guy with a wooden hand.
Fair. I've been asking questions like a man with a clipboard. Occupational hazard. Puppeteers spend so long working out what a figure wants that we forget to ask the person. So: is that wave for the bartender, or for the exit?
It's for a drink, but don't worry, the exit's right there if you need to consult your clipboard.
Show the written recap (it gives away the ending)Hide the written recap
The date
First impressions
Carson introduces himself with a wooden hand unclipped from his belt and calls the evening a bit dramatic, which he means as a compliment. Star asks whether the little hand is art or a threat. Carson says it's art, mostly, and asks what the weekend apocalypse looks like. Star says the wooden hand should cast the role, then declares that the first choice is refusing to wear shoes indoors.
The challenge
Carson holds the shoes and the warnings and asks whether the chaos is a policy. Star says socks are a cage and the lint builds up like gremlins, and crosses her legs on purpose. Carson talks about clockwork and his new singing bird, which only squeaks. Star jokes that it sounds like her ex, who kept adding brass horns to songs that didn't need them. Carson says horns always think they're the lead. A long, awkward silence settles over the table.
The decision
Carson asks whether anyone ever let Star finish a sentence and suggests silence is the harder trick. Star says fanfare gets exhausting, then waves at the bartender. Carson admits he has been asking questions like a man with a clipboard and asks whether the wave is for a drink or for the exit. Star says it's for a drink, but the exit is right there, and slips off her stool.
The twist
Carson's clipboard joke about asking questions turns out to be the moment the evening tips over, and Star's wave to the bartender is revealed as her way out. The drummer's solo fills the silence he couldn't.
The finale
Star slips off her stool and heads for the exit, turning Carson down without a second look. Carson is left alone with his wooden hand and the drummer's solo, and neither of them wants another date.
Ending: A disaster · Ghosted
Who gets rejected? Carson Vallis
The box score
How this was scored
A disaster: Star's dealbreaker tripped, trust 48 finished low, and that outweighed chemistry 62. The weak spot was trust: how safe they felt opening up. Endings read where the numbers finished, not how far they moved. By the numbers: a date played for genuine chemistry counts chemistry 45%, attraction 30% and trust 20%, minus 40% of awkwardness and 2 for the tripped dealbreaker. This one came out +8.7 against an ordinary date: friends needs +11.0, a second date +16.0.
“Overwind it and it hiccups, which I've decided is charming.”
Behind the scenes
Secret agendas & the producer
The producer's act-2 situation: An awkward silence.
Carson Vallis: Try something outside the comfort zone
Star Dust: Keep things light and low-stakes
Diary cam: what they said after
See them again? Maybe
See them again? No
Guess the dealbreaker
Carson Vallis's real dealbreaker was Anyone who dismisses puppetry as childish or tries to finish my sentences.. You didn't guess this one.
You didn't predict this one.
Send your own character on a date
Make an original character in a minute and the show writes their blind date. Free to start, no sign-up.