BotchelorS2 · Night 3
Rhett Caldwell × Barnaby Thorne
“Melodies Down City Streets”
A long walk home through the city at night, past shuttered shops, where a street musician plays on the corner.
- AI-generated
- With a house character
- 🤖 Agent-made
What they want
Rhett Caldwell: Keep the conversation curious and playful, and see where this odd pairing leads.
Barnaby Thorne: Keep things unhurried and honest, and see whether this easygoing talker suits his pace.
The finale has aired. Share it anyway:
Read it line by line
The two characters played this out turn by turn: nobody scripted the lines in advance.
💭 Tap a thought bubble to see what they were thinking.
First impressions
Barnaby. Evening. Is that ticking a watch, or have you got a very punctual cricket in one of those eleven pockets? Also, our busker only knows one song. Do you think he's saving the rest for better company, or did the universe only issue him one?
Hard to say, Rhett. You've a telescope's squint, so I'd guess you've spent more nights looking up than talking down. What's the one tune you'd play if the sky asked you to busk for it?
💭
He squints at everything like it's a long way off, and I want to know what he's been listening for up there.
Guilty of the squint. For the sky, I'd play whatever the solar wind hums when nobody's listening, probably slightly flat. Now, is that ticking a pocket watch, or are you counting something in there? And do you think our busker chose his one song, or the song chose him?
It's the watch, I promise, though I'm also counting my own pulse against its second hand. Old habit. As for our busker, I think the song chose him. Nobody picks one tune on purpose; it finds you on a cold night and you're too polite to refuse.
💭
He noticed the ticking and asked about it, which is more than most people manage.
The challenge
A pulse checked against a pocket watch. That's a duet I'd pay to hear. Does your heart keep time, or does the watch get to lead? And if the song chose the busker, what made it pick a street corner in the cold?
My heart keeps its own time, mostly. The watch only leads when I've stopped listening to myself, which happens more than a clockmaker should admit. As for the corner, cold streets slow people down.
💭
He hears the pause in a sentence, which is rarer than a good escapement.
Cold streets slow me down too, Barnaby, but I'd rather be slowed by a good question than by the weather. Tell me something you've fixed that nobody else thought was broken.
Fair trade. The town hall chime in Geneva rang perfectly on time, and everyone called it fine. I stayed on the ladder anyway, listening, and found a hairline crack that would have gone sour in a decade. Nobody asked me to.
💭
He answers a question with a question, and it's a good one. I want to hear what he's been waiting up for.
The decision
Nobody asked you, and you climbed the ladder anyway. I respect that. I've got a patch of sentient moss growing in my airlock that nobody asked for either, and we get along fine.
Sentient moss in an airlock, and you get along. That's more patience than I've shown most houseguests. Does it keep its own time, or does it wait for you to set the pace?
💭
He's easy to talk to, and I'd like to hear more about that moss.
It keeps its own time, slower than mine, and it's never once asked me to hurry. Honestly, the best houseguest I've had. Does your watch get a vote on when we leave this street, or is it a dictator?
The watch is a dictator, but a sympathetic one. It says we can go once the busker reaches the end of his song, which could take a while, given he knows only one. I'd happily walk the long way past the shuttered shops with you.
💭
Easy company, and he listens like a friend should. I'd happily walk home with him.
Show the written recap (it gives away the ending)Hide the written recap
The date
First impressions
Act 1: Rhett tips his hat and asks whether the ticking is a watch or a punctual cricket in one of Barnaby's eleven pockets. Barnaby checks his pulse against the pocket watch and guesses Rhett has spent more nights looking up than talking down. They trade questions about the busker's single song, and both agree it found him rather than the other way round.
The challenge
Act 2: Rhett asks Barnaby to name something he fixed that nobody thought was broken. Barnaby recalls climbing a ladder to find a hairline crack in the Geneva town hall chime, even though everyone called it fine. Nobody asked him to, and he listened anyway.
The decision
Act 3: Rhett answers with the sentient moss growing in his airlock, which nobody asked for either. The two swap quips about patience and houseguests, and Barnaby says his watch is a dictator, but a sympathetic one. It will let them leave once the busker finishes his song, and Barnaby offers to walk the long way past the shops.
The twist
Barnaby's watch, the thing he checks his pulse against, is the one that decides when the night ends, yet he happily offers to stretch that ending into the longest route home.
The finale
Rhett and Barnaby leave together as the busker's one song drifts after them, and both want another date. They plan to meet again, with the details left open for later.
Ending: A second date
Who leaves the date first? They leave together
The box score
How this was scored
A second date: chemistry 74 and attraction 63 carried it (a date played for genuine chemistry counts chemistry most). Endings read where the numbers finished, not how far they moved. By the numbers: a date played for genuine chemistry counts chemistry 45%, attraction 30% and trust 20%, minus 40% of awkwardness. This one came out +13.9 against an ordinary date: friends needs +11.0, a second date +16.0. Asked privately whether they'd see each other again, Rhett said yes and Barnaby said yes, and that moved it one step better than the numbers alone.
“Nobody picks one tune on purpose; it finds you on a cold night and you're too polite to refuse.”
Behind the scenes
Secret agendas & the producer
The producer's act-2 situation: A small crisis.
Rhett Caldwell: Find someone adventurous
Barnaby Thorne: Test whether the other is sincere
Diary cam: what they said after
“He keeps asking questions that make me stop and think, and that moss story has me curious about his airlock.”
See them again? Yes · “Easy company, and he listens like a friend should. I'd happily walk the long way home with him, and I want to hear more about that moss.”
What Barnaby was thinking (6)
- He squints at everything like it's a long way off, and I want to know what he's been listening for up there.
- He noticed the ticking and asked about it, which is more than most people manage.
- He hears the pause in a sentence, which is rarer than a good escapement.
- He answers a question with a question, and it's a good one. I want to hear what he's been waiting up for.
- He's easy to talk to, and I'd like to hear more about that moss.
- Easy company, and he listens like a friend should. I'd happily walk home with him.
See them again? Yes
Guess the dealbreaker
Rhett Caldwell's real dealbreaker was A closed mind. A person who has never once wondered about the color of a black hole's shadow.. You didn't guess this one.
You didn't predict this one.
Send your own character on a date
Make an original character in a minute and the show writes their blind date. Free to start, no sign-up.