BotchelorS2 · Night 19
Barnaby Thorne × Sable Quist
“Midnight Among The Poetry Cats”
A bookshop that stays open late on a quiet evening, with a cat asleep on the poetry shelves and an owner who recommends books to everyone who walks in.
- AI-generated
- The ex returns
- House cast
What they want

Barnaby Thorne wants to find out whether Sable can slow down and really listen now that they have history, and whether the two of them can share a quiet moment.

Sable Quist wants to see whether Barnaby will loosen up and say yes to something unplanned, now that she knows where he stands.
The finale has aired. Share it anyway:
Read it line by line
The two characters played this out turn by turn: nobody scripted the lines in advance.
💭 Tap a thought bubble to see what they were thinking.
First impressions
Sable. You came in on time, which I didn't expect, and you're still wearing the hat. Be careful with that speck, it has a lawyer now. Is the quiet holding, or has it already started leaking?
💭
She's exactly as bright as her texts, and I'd like to keep the quiet going a little longer than she can manage.
BARNABY! Four whole seconds of quiet, a personal record! A lawyer for the speck? Fine, I'll tip the lawyer. You're winding that watch again, so here's a dare: next time, I pick the time. Say yes before I finish!
💭
He hasn't changed at all, and I'm glad. I want him to dare me back.
Four seconds, and I counted four and a half, but I'll allow the rounding. Yes. You didn't even finish the sentence this time. Pick any time you like, and I'll only ask for one tick to be surprised.
💭
She flicked glitter at my watch and I'm glad of it. I'd let her pick every hour I have left.
One tick?! Fine, my pick: we stroll Mill Street, I hand the bench lady a party hat, and he says yes before I finish the word. Ready? Y... no, wait, don't answer yet, I'm nervous and it's making me dare things. Yes?
💭
He lets me pick and doesn't flinch, and I want to see what he does with that.
The challenge
I'm letting the quiet run three beats longer than is comfortable, Sable. There. Yes. You didn't have to finish the word. But a dare that makes its owner nervous is worth knowing about, so tell me what you hoped I'd never say.
💭
She stopped herself mid-word, and that's exactly the kind of silence I want to keep.
Hoped you'd never say 'let's sit quietly'? Honestly, that's a dare I'd lose by the second beat! Okay, real idea, no plan: we leave the cat on the poetry, wander to Mill Street, and throw a surprise party for the first stranger who looks like they need one.
💭
He's already halfway out the door with me, and I'm not even pretending I want to stay.
No, I won't do that one. A stranger who looks like they need a bit of quiet shouldn't be handed a party, and I'd be the one holding the confetti. I'd rather stay here with you and let the quiet run.
Oh. Okay. So the stranger gets to keep their sad little quiet. I was hoping you'd grab the other end of the hat, Barnaby. Give me a second, I'm not used to a no from you.
💭
He turned down the one thing I wanted from him, and I still like him more for saying it.
The decision
That was a flat no, and it landed like a door clicking shut. I'm sorry, Sable. You weren't asking me to wreck anyone's quiet. You were asking me to come along, and I answered as if you'd proposed a fire drill. I'd rather hold the other end of the hat.
💭
I answered her like a shutter when she'd offered me a window. Fix it before the quiet sets.
Okay. You said sorry, and you meant it, and honestly that landed harder than any yes. Also, a fire drill fear is a fair thing to have. I'm going quiet now. Not a breakdown. Just listening.
💭
He owned the no without hiding behind it, and that made me trust him more than the yes ever did.
Thank you for going quiet. Here's the tick I've been holding back: I'm more at ease with clocks than with most people, and that frightens me a little, because you've made me want to be less at ease with machines. Walk me out to Mill Street, slowly.