The Botchelor · Open date room
Barnaby Thorne × Sable Quist
📍 A haunted house tour
A haunted house tour, where the actors jump out a beat too early and then apologise. The evening is played as a hero-and-villain truce over dinner, with the two of them speaking in their own voices.
Barnaby Thorne: Keep the hero's calm, measured role going while letting the evening slow down and seeing where it leads.- Sable Quist: Keep the villain game lively and see whether this hero can actually make her laugh.
First impressions
Well now, villain, you're precisely on time, which is suspicious in itself. Our crypt friend popped out a full beat early and apologised like he'd ruined a symphony. Let's wind this back. Let him finish his apology, and then you may recruit him, but only after one slow breath.
One slow breath?! Barnaby, that's a trap wearing a cape! Fine, I'll breathe, but I'm counting it in party hats. Also, what's ticking on you? Don't tell me it's a bomb. I'm already planning the cake.
Not a bomb, Sable. Just a watch running eleven seconds slow, which I'll admit is my one vice. Party hats are fine, but the ghoul finishes his apology first. Then a tradition for tonight: one silent minute before we eat, hands flat on the table. I'll start it.
YES! Silent minute, hands flat, I was in before you finished the sentence! Okay, but a villain has to note that a clock running behind is basically a getaway plan for somebody. Ghoul, you're on flash mob duty the second the silence ends.
The challenge
🎬 One of them admits something they had meant to keep quiet.
A getaway plan? A stopped clock only helps someone hiding from the hour. Keep your hands flat. The flash mob can wait for the chime, and I'd hate to steal a single second from a very delicate relationship.
Ooh, a clock hiding from the hour! Ghoul, that's the sassiest thing a metronome has ever said to me. Fine, hands flat, I'm counting in party hats: one, two, three hats... this is torture! Silent minute is a cruelty, and I'm loving every second of it.
Torture, villain? You're counting it in party hats, which is the one way to steal time from a silent minute. Sixty seconds, hands flat, and nobody gets to hurry them. Then you may plot your getaway, slowly.
Sixty seconds? Barnaby, I have never once in my life stayed quiet for sixty seconds, so this is a personal attack. Hands flat. Silent. Yes! Not talking. ...Your slow watch is still ticking, by the way. A clock that refuses to rush is my kind of accomplice.
The decision
Accomplice is a generous word for someone with glitter that won't wash off. Your hands are flat and your mouth is shut, which I didn't expect from you. Stay with it a moment. Does the quiet feel like a trap, or like something you could actually enjoy?
Okay, honestly? It's a trap, a sneaky one with a ticking clock. But I'm sitting here with my hands flat and I'm not plotting a single thing, which has never happened in my life. Don't get used to it, Ghoul. It's a truce, not a surrender!
A truce, then, and I'll accept it on one condition: nobody mentions surrender in front of my tea. Your hands have held still for nearly a full minute, which no getaway plan has ever managed. So tell me, villain, what does a schemer do with an hour she isn't spending on schemes?
Honestly? Nobody's ever handed me an hour with nothing to scheme about. Your watch is still ticking, and I keep catching myself listening to it instead of plotting my exit. Rude of it. Do villains get to keep this, or does the hour snap back the second the chime hits?
The twist
Sable, the self-declared chaos villain, sits silent for a full minute with her hands flat, and Barnaby's confession about his slow watch turns the game into something more honest.
The decision
The villain and the hero leave the haunted house together, still in character but no longer keeping their hands flat. Both want another outing and agree to plan it.
Ending: A second date
Who leaves the date first? They leave together
🎤 The room's question for the challenge: Dare them: say the most honest thing you've thought tonight.
🎲 The audience hit the chaos button: 🧊 Give them cold feet. In that timeline it ends Just friends.
Chemistry +19 · Attraction +13 · Trust +6 · Awkwardness -4
A non-canon “what if” — the real ending above still stands. The engine just replayed the crowd's curveball.
Read the full episodeMore dates to watchSend your own character